©Copyright 2004-2007 • Contact Us Home Polemics Essays Archives Letters
Permanent Revolution
                
Tatlin's Tower - Monument to the Third International        PERMANENT REVOLUTION

  Trotsky on Nietzsche - Now available in English !
  On the Philosophy of the Superman, Oct. 30, 2011
 RECENT PUBLICATIONS
 Independence of the Ukraine and Sectarian Muddleheads, June 7, 2014
 Trotsky on Ukraine: Lessons for Today, May 20, 2014
 Comment on whither Ukraine, March 25, 2014
 Whither Ukraine, March 1, 2014
 A Case of Magical Thinking, Dec 15, 2013
 A Case Study in the Neglect of Dialectics, Oct. 23, 2013
 The Mexican teacher's peaceful “insurrection”, Oct. 12, 2013
 The arrest of the Golden Dawn Nazi Gangsters in Greece, Oct. 7, 2013
 From the trial of the antifascists to a murder by the fascists, Sept. 24, 2013
 The Battle for the Zócalo, Sept. 21, 2013
 Mexico: At a Crossroads or an impasse? Sept. 13, 2013
 Charges against Savas Michael Matsas thrown out by judge, Sept. 5, 2013
 Turkish: Lev Trotskiy’in suikastle katledilmesinin 73. yıldönümü üzerine
 On the 73rd Anniversary of the Assassination of Trotsky, August 21,2013
 Defend Savas Michael against the Golden Dawn fascists!, August 6,2013
 Left Forum: Hegel's Philosophy of History and its legacy for the Left, June 30,2013
 Left Forum: God as the Mob: right wing representations of Hegel, June 29,2013
 Reading Marx in Teheran, June 14,2013
 Left Forum: Too Long in Lincoln's Shadow, June 11,2013
 Marshall Sahlins on Human Science, May 25,2013
 May Day 2013 in Athens, May 1,2013
 Wallace Shawn: Why I call myself a socialist, April 3,2013
 [Turkish] Otomobil işçileri Türk Metal bürokrasisine isyan ettiler, Dec 7,2012
 Auto workers revolt at Renault factory in Turkey, Nov 18,2012
 95th Anniversary of the Russian Revolution, Nov 7,2012
 North and Service on Trotsky's Attitude to Plekhanov, Oct 9,2012
 [Greek] Αθήνα: άποψη της γενικής απεργίας, Sept 26,2012
 [Greek] Ελλάδα: Κατάρρευση των παραδοσιακών κομμάτων, Sept 24,2012
 [Turkish] Atina: Genel Greve bir Bakış, Sept 26,2012
 [Turkish] Yunanistan: Geleneksel partilerin çöküsü, Sept 24,2012
 Athens: A View of the General Strike, Sept 26,2012
 Greece: Collapse of the traditional parties, Sept 24,2012
 Turkish: Trotskiy'in Öldürülmesinin 72. Yıldönümünde, Trotskiy'in torunu Esteban Volkov'la yapılan görüşme
 72nd Anniversary of Trotsky's Assassination: Interview with Esteban Volkov
 Review: Left Forum 2012
 Turkish: New York Belediye Başkanı Wall Street’i Işgal Et protestocularını zorla tahliye etti ! Nov. 18, 2011
 New York Mayor evicts Occupy Wall Street! Nov. 16, 2011
 German: Die PSG und die Wahlen zum Berliner Abgeordnetenhaus 2011, Oct. 31, 2011
 The PSG and the 2011 Berlin state elections, Oct. 29, 2011
 Eyewitness account from Occupy Oakland police riot, Oct. 29, 2011
 Turkish: Türkiye ekonomisinde yanılsama ve gerçeklik, Oct. 16, 2011
 Impresiones de la ocupación de Wall Street! Oct. 12, 2011
 Impressions from Occupy Wall Street! Oct. 6, 2011
 Illusion and reality in the Turkish economy, Oct. 2, 2011
 On the 71st Anniversary of the Assassination of Trotsky, Aug. 21, 2011
 Important new article on the crisis of contemporary psychiatry, Aug. 12, 2011
 A Comment on David Bruce's 'A Charlatan Exposed', July 8, 2011
 Eye witness account of the events in Syntagma Square, Athens
 Letter not published by WSWS on nuclear energy crisis
  Are you OK? Impressions of May Day 2011
 Satirizing the left: comment on a cartoon about the Left Forum
  From the Archives of the International Committee: A Charlatan Exposed: A Reply to Gerry Healy's 'Studies in Dialectical Materialism'
  Presentations at the Left Forum: Alex Steiner and Q & A
  Presentations at the Left Forum: Harrison Fluss
  Presentations at the Left Forum: Frank Brenner and Charles Herr
  Insults and intimidation: An SEP 'intervention' at the Left Forum
  Some Reflections on the Revolution in Egypt
  Blog Archives
  Other Recent Publications >>
  BOOKS
  The Downward Spiral of the International Committee of the Fourth International
 Español : Espiral descendente del Comité Internacional de la IV Internacional
  Marxism Without its Head or its Heart
 Afterword to Marxism Without its Head or its Heart
 CATEGORIES
 Polemics polemics
 Essays in Philosophy, History, Psychology and Culture
 From the Archives of the International Committee
 Letters to Permanent Revolution
 Permanent Revolution Forum
 Links
 Contact Us

Marxism Without its Head or its Heart:

A Reply to David North

To the members and supporters of the International Committee of the Fourth International:
For three years we tried to engage the leadership of the ICFI in a discussion over grave concerns we had about the theoretical and political orientation of the movement. Finally David North responded to our documents with his Marxism, History and Socialist Consciousness. It isn’t empty rhetoric on our parts to say that we would have welcomed being proven wrong. This would have demonstrated the basic political health of the IC, to say nothing of sparing us the thankless task of pursuing this polemic any further. Instead, North has produced a dreadful piece of work that only confirms in a striking manner all the concerns we have raised. It is a document that is rife with misrepresentations and evasions, it compounds serious political errors of judgment by stridently refusing to acknowledge them ...

Marx

Marx

Paris Commune poster

Paris Commune poster

Street demonstration, Petrograd, 18 June 1917. The banner in the foreground reads Down With The 10 Capitalist Ministers, All Power To The Soviets Of Workers', Soldiers', And Peasants' Deputies, And To The Socialist Ministers, We Demand That Nicholas II Be Transfered To The Peter-Paul Fortress.

Street demonstration, Petrograd, 18 June 1917.

©Copyright 2004-2007 • Contact Us Home